Wednesday, March 2, 2011

The Great Computer Science vs Computing Science Debate!

The College Board is proposing a new course entitled CS Principles, http://csprinciples.org, that students could take before the current AP CS course or instead of it. Wouldn't a course in Computing Science or Scientific Computing plus Discrete Mathematics be more useful to students wanting an alternative or an intro to the current AP CS course? 


I have spent this whole school year reworking my intro course to include a Computer Algebra System (SAGE) and a new programming language (python, new to my school anyway) and a new text on Discrete Mathematics (the Litvins' Mathematics for the Digital Age, http://www.skylit.com). I think my introCS students are getting alot out of this approach. It certainly sounds more rigorous than the propsed CS Principles. 


Sorry, I don't mean to offend anyone. I know alot of the people developing this course are top notch. I just don't see this as a good direction for the future of APs in Computer Science. I know the intent is a good one. We want more students to do more Computer Science in High School and Undergrad. If a student's first exposure to Computer Science is the current AP course, it may not always go well. Also, if a student only does one year of Computer Science, I think they are missing out. So, a program like CS Principles does have potential, but I would define the curriculum differently (see below).


If I had my druthers, I'd love to see the following sequence of courses.
 
APCS1: 
Discrete Math with CAS as described above. My school used to call this course Computer Math. Some call it Computing Science or Scientific Computing. On the python edu-sig forum they are coining the phrase Digital Math. I've been teaching a course like this since the late 1980s. In fact, I've been teaching programming with some sort of BASIC (IBM BASICA, MS QBASIC, Visual BASIC, REALbasic, yabasic, etc) since 1975! I only just switched to python this year. Over the years, I've also used ForTran, Pascal, C, C++, Java, SAGE, Octave and R in this course. We've even played with html and applets for the web.
 
APCS2: 
The current APCS course is mostly about algorithms and Object Oriented Programming aka APCS A. The current course, using java, is sufficient. We even do a little computer history, computer literacy and computer ethics! This course is especially beautiful given the right text. I highly recommend anything by Cay Horstmann. See http://www.horstmann.com 


APCS1 and APCS2 are usually followed by a Data Structures, Networking or Operating Systems course. Some schools do robotics or website design. I would follow APCS1 and APCS2, as described above, with APCS3 or APCS4 as described below.

APCS3: 
The old APCS course that was canceled about Data Structures aka APCS AB should be brought back. A standard course in linked lists and binary trees would be great!
 
APCS4: 
A new course in multicore, cluster, grid computing and clouds would be timely! I've been running a Computing Independent Study course, aka CIS(theta), for seniors who have already taken AP Computer Science as juniors. Lately we've been learning about SAGE, Octave and R. We've also set up clusters using PVM, MPI and openMosix doing some applications involving fractals, povray, blender and even some number crunching. We've also played with various Linux distros to get our cluster running: clusterKnoppix, BCCD, Quantian, OSCAR, Rocks, centOS, Fedora, Ubuntu, Cluster By Night, parallelKnoppix and pelicanHPC.

What do ya think? 

Teaching with Technology, 

Tuesday, March 1, 2011

Spock, Birthdays and Pheasants!

Here's a random pic from class where GrahamS and ChrisS explain how to play "Rock, Paper, Scissors, Lizard, Spock!" So, Rock crushes Scissors and Rock smashes Lizzard.  Also, Paper covers Rock and Paper disproves Spock. Now, Scissors cuts Paper and Scissors decapitates Lizard. Then, Lizard eats Paper and Lizard poisons Spock. Finally, Spock vaporizes Rock and Spock phasers Scissors? IDK about that last one....


Here's another pic from last weekend outside my daughter's Sunday School. Can you make out the wild turkeys? Actually, I think they are declared as a protected species on Long Island. Aren't those Ring-Necked Pheasants? All kinds of beasts come out of those woods when you least expect it. Last month it was a whole deer family! This is a tribe of pheasants. I think there were 13 or 14 all together!


Finally, a pic from last month on my birthday 2/8/11. BTW, my students owe me a 100% on a test or quiz for my birthday! It was the 20th anniversary of my 29th birthday. Gotta love Carvel....


Generally Speaking,

Monday, February 21, 2011

NOVA, NOVA Everywhere!

I've been showing YouTubes in class on Wednesdays for several years now. Usually I'll show 5 or 10 minute clips of an educational YouTube something to do with what we are learning in class. I have several students in Computing and Math classes, so I try to show something different in each.



Lately, I've been showing NOVAs. There's a good one from 1985 called the Mathematical Mystery Tour about the great unsolved problems of Mathematics with interviews of some of the top Mathematicians of the time about how they do math.



I've also been showing one in my Computing classes about Clifford Stoll and the Cookoo's egg virus. I think this one is from around 1988 and its all about the dawn of the internet and a ring of hackers Clifford tracked down while working in the IT dept at LBL.


Watch the full episode. See more NOVA.

The last year has seen a number of new NOVAs that are very good. One is about the life of Beniot Mandelbrot in particular and fractals in general.


Watch the full episode. See more NOVA.

Another NOVA that was on last week was about the IBM supercomputer called Watson and a match it had against some Jeopardy champions. My Computing Independent Study class is upset with Watson. They've been working hard all year to get all 50 cores in my classroom to work as a single Linux Cluster. We finally harnessed all 50 AMD 64bit Athlons and got Shadowfax running at 24 GFLPOS. Well, Watson runs at 72 TFLOPS and has 3000 processors. So, Watson is 3000 times faster than Shadowfax and one of Watson's cores is equivalent to all our 50 cores put together. In other words, my entire PC Lab/Classroom/Cluster is just one chip out of 3000 on Watson....

My 21st Century Math Classroom!


I've been waiting ALL YEAR for the tech dept to get me internet access on my new sftp/ftp/SAGE servers....

So, I am using sftp on the new server for my AP Computer Science class to do their classwork. I gave them an Ubuntu Desktop as a client and setup the new server as an Ubuntu Desktop plus openssh so they can write their java programs.  I also added vsftp to that server so I can share some files with them. The problem is that all this is only available to them during class! My old servers had external IPs as well so my students could work from home.

I also used to share all my SmartNotebook pdfs and http://screencast-o-matic.com mp4s on the old ftp server for my Math students to access from home. Access to these files from home was a great added resource to my classes. If a student is absent, they can easily see what was missed and catch up. If a particular topic is giving the student difficulty, he or she could load up the files from that class and review what we did even if it was months ago! I am using the new server as an ftp site too, but its only accessible in school via Linux. That's great for my computing students except for no access off campus. However, most of my Math students don't use Linux and liked accessing these files from home.

Enter the 21st Century Mathematics Classroom! I just started uploading my pdfs to http://www.slideshare.net/calcpage2011 just like my old ftp site. Also, all my videos are already on http://www.youtube.com/calcpage2009 for my students to view. I'm also looking at http://www.edmodo.com to link all these resources together! Edmodo is fashoined after Facebook, so the students know how to use it already. I created a teacher account. Then I added a group for each of my classes. Each group gets a unique access code that you can give to your students. When they make a student account, they provide the access code and get a private Facebook-like wall for the course. On that wall I can post assignments for the week and links to the slideshare pdfs and youtube mp4s.

BTW, just for the record, I take full responsibly for coining the following terms.

MultipleChoice Mondays: 
I give an entire Part IA or Part IB every other Monday. I give AB exams in the Fall and BC exams in the Spring. I have my students complete only as many as one class period allows based on real AP exam time limits (about 2 minutes per question without a calculator and 3 minutes per question with). I start this around Thanksgiving after we finish most AB topics in my BC class. One week is the exam, the following Monday we go over it in class. In this manner, we cover 10 Parts I in the 20 weeks leading up to AP Week. 
 
TakeHome Tuesdays, 
I give one take home per quarter with Free Response Questions of my own making that review what we've done so far and extend the students' knowledge using topics from AP Physics C Mechanics as I have a lot of those students in my BC Calculus class. 
 
YouTube Wednesdays: 
I show a funny 5-10 minute clip (Calculus Carols, etc) or part of a documantary related to class usually from YouTube, sometimes Ted, sometimes PBS/Nova (see current blog post about Nova). 
 
Think-a-lot Thursdays: 
Every 2-3 weeks, when we finish a unit, I give a pretest reviewing topics on the test the next day. Students are placed in groups of 3-4 and compete for bonus points as a group toward individual test on Friday. 
 
FreeResponse Fridays: 
Every 2-3 week unit ends in a test of my own design similar to past Free Response questions emphasizing the use of technology.  

Teaching with Technology, 

There's old teachers and there's bold teachers, but there's no old bold teachers???

Holy cow, if I have to hear the argument that "tenured/experienced teachers are not dedicated to their profession or their students, just sit on their asses all day and should be replaced" I will explode! Take a look at this article: http://voices.washingtonpost.com/ezra-klein/2011/02/are_wisconsins_state_and_local.html


 Generally Speaking,

Sunday, February 13, 2011

CIS(theta) Meeting X (2010-2011) - Time to switch gears!

Aim: 
Time to switch gears!

Attending: 




The school networks were down this week. So, we didn't get much done except for talking a lot! We decided that we should look into alternatives to the cluster solutions we've been trying of late. See the readings and research sections above for some ideas.



Maybe we should just break down and install openMPI directly onto our Ubuntu Desktop? What about fractal renderings, povray scenes and blender sequences using non-traditional clusters? It may be time for a change! 



Well, that's all for this week!  Please stay tuned.  We hope this record will help others trying to make their own clusters.  Also, if you have any hints or pointers, please leave a comment to let us know.  

Happy Clustering,

CIS(theta) Meeting X (2010-2011) - Time to switch gears!

Aim: 
Time to switch gears!

Attending: 




The school networks were down this week. So, we didn't get much done except for talking a lot! We decided that we should look into alternatives to the cluster solutions we've been trying of late. See the readings and research sections above for some ideas.



Maybe we should just break down and install openMPI directly onto our Ubuntu Desktop? What about fractal renderings, povray scenes and blender sequences using non-traditional clusters? It may be time for a change! 



Well, that's all for this week!  Please stay tuned.  We hope this record will help others trying to make their own clusters.  Also, if you have any hints or pointers, please leave a comment to let us know.  

Happy Clustering,